Latest Prendos Property Talk
 
 
 
 
 An Example Layout
 
 
 
 
 
DISPUTE RESOLUTION NEGOTIATION HAS FAILED-WHAT NEXT
gREG   By Greg O'Sullivan MNZIBS, FAMINZ, Dip. Bus. Stud (Dispute Resolution)

LEADR Panel (med) Arbitrator, Mediator, Registered Building Surveyor, BRANZ Accredited Adviser

 
 
Parties involved in disputes often have issues to deal with from the outset ? things that should have been discussed even before the contract was signed. Sadly the valuable tool of early negotiation is often overlooked. Unwittingly, parties have established a likely path to future breakdown of the contract. Too often, the result is a disintegration of the parties relationship and the establishment of a dispute. Even at this stage, parties adopt a strong stand on their own position and fail to resolve issues through negotiation. Now they are trapped in a dispute cycle.

What often happens next is that anger leads to entrenchment and bitterness, which prevents parties seeing possible solutions.

In an ideal world they should ask themselves questions like the following:

What is the issue for us?
What is the state of the contract?
How are we following the contract conditions?
Is what we want possible?
What is the least we could accept?
What other options do we have?
What can we live with?

Failure to ask these questions and understand one's true position can be a real trap. As an arbitrator and mediator I have listened to parties and heard them fail to understand or hear the other party's concerns. In a sense being a mediator is a little like looking at people through a two-way mirror. I can see the whole dispute from both sides and yet so often the parties are missing vital parts of the argument.

It is my firm belief that parties who are dealing with a developing dispute should seek immediate advice – both legal and expert. They should ask both sets of advisers to help them work out their actual position, including strengths and weaknesses. They should ask for the best and worst scenarios and not wait for those advisers to feel compelled to give them. In particular, they should ask the expert to provide a clear balanced view so they know what their choices are. Perfection in advice may be impossible but providing a reasonable understanding to parties of the position is not. This does not eliminate advocacy. Sometimes, particular points need to be tested further. This testing process helps parties decide on the best method of dispute resolution for them and it often brings parties to the point where they can see that some form of settlement may be a very good option.

Whether you choose to litigate, arbitrate, or mediate a dispute, make sure you have sufficient information about the dispute, your options and the dispute resolution techniques available.

 
 
Auckland
34 Barrys Point Road, Takapuna
PO Box 33-700, Takapuna,AKL 0740
Phone: (09) 970 7070
Fax: (09) 970 7072
Tauranga
22 Tukorako Drive,
PO Box 5189, Mount Maunganui 3150
Phone: (07) 927 7070
Fax: (07) 927 0760 
Wellington
Unit 4B, 33 Kaiwharawhara Road,
PO Box 11 123, Wellington 6142
Phone: (04) 931 7070
Fax: (04) 931 7072
Christchurch
6/45 Acheron Drive, Riccarton
PO Box 8049 Riccarton CHC 8440
Phone: (03) 341 7570
Fax: (03) 341 7572 
© 2010 Prendos NZ Ltd. All rights reserved.